Appendix N

Cumulative Statistics on Exceedances, Complaints, Notifications of Summons and Successful Prosecutions

 

Cumulative statistics on Exceedances

 

Total no. recorded in this month

Total no. recorded since project commencement 

1-Hour TSP

Action

-

-

Limit

-

-

24-Hour TSP

Action

-

-

Limit

-

-

Noise

Action

-

-

Limit

-

-

Water Quality

Action

1

1

Limit

1

1

Dolphin Monitoring

Action

-

-

Limit

-

-

Remarks: Exceedances which are not project-related are not presented in this table.

 

Cumulative statistics on Exceedances, Complaints, Notifications of Summons and Successful Prosecutions

 

Date Received

Subject

Status

Total no. received in this month

Total no. received since project commencement 

Environmental complaints

11 Nov 13

As informed by the Contractor, complaint received from Penta-Ocean – Gitanes Joint Venture (CV/2012/03) mentioned that the formation works of the Contaminated Mud Pit CMP1 to the South of the Brothers (CMP1 of SB) which has been completed in mid-August 2013 and the pit has been commissioned for receiving contaminated marine mud from other projects starting from 16 August 2013. However, it was recently observed that some of the project vessels of HY/2010/02 (photos taken on 20 Nov 2013 are attached) had berthed within the said pit and those anchorages would likely cause disruption to the underlying contaminated mud and thus induce unfavourable contamination impact to the surrounding marine environment. In this regard, they reminded the contractor to avoid berthing of their vessels within the boundary of CMP1 of SB thereafter for the sake of environmental concern. After investigation, the complaint was considered as non-project related

 

Closed

 

11

12 Nov 13

As informed by the Contractor on 5 Dec13, one complaint was noted on 12 Nov regarding a barge moving through the southern channel. After investigation, the noise complaint was considered as non-project related

 

Closed

 

12

12 Dec 13

As informed by the Contractor on 12 Dec 13. A complaint involves the leakage of sand from barges causing water discoloration at sea near Tuen Mun Pierhead Garden and sand material without properly covered was blown to the inside of the residential area which caused disturbance to residence. With refer to available information provided and monitoring data recorded on 09 Dec 13, it cannot indicate that the water quality impact and air quality impact were caused by the vessel of this Contract and therefore the complaint could not be concluded as related to this Contract.

 

Closed

1

13

 

27 Dec 13

As informed by the Contractor on 27 Dec 13. A complaint involves barges loaded with sand material without properly covered was blown to the inside of the residential area of Tuen Mun Pierhead Garden which caused disturbance to residence. With refer to available information provided, it cannot indicate that the water quality impact and air quality impact were caused by the vessel of this Contract and therefore the complaint could not be concluded as related to this Contract.

 

Closed

2

14

Notification of summons

-

-

-

-

1

Successful Prosecutions

 

 

 

 

1